I’m quietly trying to counsel a woman who wants to go to graduate school in (IA and Rana, hide your eyes) American history, her goal being the endangered tenure-track humanities professorship.
No, I’ve been good. Really I have. I have not screamed “RUN AWAY!” in my best tortured-animal howl, tempting though that admittedly is. I’ve just been asking the tough questions—her favorite prof was an ABD abjunct who got tossed out of the department for not finishing her dissertation, so she’s not completely clueless, just unreasonably optimistic—and suggesting some alternatives.
But there’s a bit of starry-eyed proto-grad-student folklore that irks the life out of me—again, because it used to be me—the whole “But I’ll never be happy except as a professor!” hyperbole.
It. Is. Garbage.
Except when it’s self-fulfilling prophecy, and then it’s worse than garbage—it’s knowing self-sabotage.
I have only ever heard this said by people with no concept whatever of the bewildering variety of work the world offers. You don’t know everything that’s out there. Neither do I. Let’s not predicate our lives on tunnel vision, hm?
I don’t believe in the One True Life Path thing anyway. I’ve gone and said so before. It’s a continuum; there are things you’d be miserable doing, and things that would make you die happily of overwork, and a vast array of stuff in the middle. I’m here to tell you that on the whole, somewhere in the middle is a pretty good place to be.
I’m also here to tell you that what you’re actually doing is only one part of being happy in your job. It may not even be the biggest one. I got routed out of a job whose actual job bits (if I’d been allowed to do them uninterfered-with) were wonderful. My boss, however, had taken against me, and he made my life pure unadulterated hell without half trying. I got out. The next job featured a Dragon Lady who wasn’t even my direct boss, but was so horribly unpleasant that I didn’t stay to work through some things that, honestly, could have been worked through.
This job, speaking in terms of the job itself, is frustrating when it isn’t banal. I’ve been happy in it for a year and a half, because my boss is freakin’ awesome and my coworkers are pleasant, and my conscience is completely at peace about what I’m doing.
So don’t give me that “I’ll never be happy unless…” line. I know better.
Seems worth mentioning also that predicating your entire life satisfaction on your job is horrendously narrow-minded. Talk about setting yourself up for unhappiness. Once again, the world is a big place, and satisfaction can be had in many, many parts of it.
Just, please, if you’re thinking about writing me to ask if you should go to grad school, find some real sources of life satisfaction before you lay the “I’ll only be happy as a professor!” line on me, okay? Or I’m just gonna hafta hurt you, and neither of us wants that.